She would be set up in a house there, and slowly over time she would grow incessantly insane. She would change from the lovely Margaret to Mad Mag.
Stories about her home life are often told, including killing and cooking the family cat and feeding it to her husband, burning herself on the forehead with an iron, and cutting off her toe with a cleaver.
When John Simon died, the locals did what they could for her, building a small shack in Paddy's Hollow, a low rise of dunes near Howard Street. It was also near the walking path to the coast, and many people used her front porch as a shortcut, driving her even more insane. Little kids would bang on the walls and run, while Mad Mag would come out screaming. She took to wearing her nightgown all day, and her long blonde hair grew wild and gray. She would wander the island, shrieking at demons only she saw.
When she finally passed, the island thought they were rid of her, but they would be wrong.
Now, her spirit can be seen standing in the Howard family graveyard, shrieking into the twilight, only to disappear into the night.
People have even seen her spirit wander the roads, thinking she is just another old woman, until they realize she does not speak back when they say Good Evening. And then she vanishes, walking away into the dark of the night.
Ocracoke Island Ocracoke Island - Legend of the Old Diver Ocracoke Island - Ghost of Lighthouse Keeper Ocracoke Island - Flaming Ship Ocracoke Island - The ghost of Theodosia Burr Alston Ocracoke Island - The ghost of Blackbeard Ocracoke Island - Party Girl in Blue