On August 4, 1892, Andrew and his wife, Abby Borden, were found brutally murdered in their Fall River, Massachusetts, home. Though murder wasn’t uncommon in the late 1800s, the fact that they were bludgeoned to death with an ax and the main suspect was their 32-year-old daughter, Lizzie Borden, certainly was.
The crime and trial that followed made headlines around the world. Lizzie was ultimately acquitted of murder, but she remains forever linked to the heinous killings, as does the home where the crime was committed.
Now a bed-and-breakfast and museum, the Borden home attracts history buffs and thrill-seekers who come to see for themselves if rumors that the house is haunted are, indeed, true.
“When I started working here, it was more of the history. I really didn’t care about the paranormal,” Suzanne St. John, a realtor and tour guide at the Lizzie Borden House, tells TODAY.com.
However, that all changed after St. John says she experienced a few unusual happenings of her own.
“Guests tell us they hear laughing and playing in the middle of the night, things get moved around,” she says. And St. John has experienced a few unusual things herself, saying that once she discovered toys scattered across a room that no one had been in.
St. John also talks of a picture that fell over and slid two feet across the floor without any plausible explanation, as well as a closet door that once opened on its own volition.
On the eve of the anniversary of Andrew and Abby’s murder, St. John says that she and two other tour guides at the house felt a sudden sharp, piercing pain in their left eyes — the same exact location of Andrew Borden’s fatal injuries.
Perhaps the most unsettling, however, is the story St. John tells of a tour guide at the Lizzie Borden house who asked her group to silence their cell phones before beginning the tour. Moments later, a guest’s cell phone rang. She looked up and said, “It’s my mom.”
The tour guide asked if she wanted to leave and take the call, to which the woman replied: “She died two years ago.”
Borden Murders and Trial Borden, Lizzie Lizzie and Emma Borden - After the Murders ONeil, Nance Borden, Andrew Borden Folk Rhyme Borden, Abby Sullivan, Bridget Morse, John Churchill, Adelaide Borden, Emma Lizzie Borden Alibi Bowen, Seabury Russell, Alice Fourteen Reasons to Believe Lizzie Murdered Her Parents Lizzie Borden - Net Worth Hauntings at the Borden House Hauntings at the Borden House - 2 Murder in the Well Lizzie Borden Bed and Breakfast